Christmas Candy Gifts - 30+ Easy Homemade Candy Recipes - Fickle Hobbyist (2024)

Christmas Bark

I actually wasn’t sure what category to put this one in because it’s so unique. It’s going under the Christmas Bark category because it’s similar to barks, in that the top is finished with a swirl of various chocolates and has the same texture as a bark. The bottom layer features crushed tea biscuits and chocolate covered raisins which pair nicely with the marbled chocolate layer. Prepare and slice it, or create individual sized portions in muffin cups for gifting.

Visit:My Morning Mocha

With only three ingredients, this chocolate pomegranate bark comes together super quickly, even your kids can help. The pomegranate errols and pistachios make the perfect accompaniment to the dark chocolate. It’s even vegan-friendly!

Visit:Pastry Wishes

Another, super simple, no-bake recipe, this white chocolate peppermint bark features adorable, festive sprinkles and an extra added dash of peppermint extract for the perfect holiday treat. So easy, anybody can do it. And so cute!

Visit:On My Kids Plate

For a vegan take on your favorite Christmas bark, look no further. This recipe uses vegan dark chocolate and white chocolate chips to compliment the crushed peppermint sprinkle on top. The two layers take the classic bark up a notch.

Visit:Wow It’s Veggie

Christmas Brittles & Toffees

Rich molasses and warm gingerbread spices give this homemade toffee a seasonal twist. The flavors just scream Christmas. Anybody would be thrilled to receive this treat with its unique take on a traditional Christmas toffee.

Visit:Burrata and Bubbles

This oat brittle recipe is the perfect substitution for the person in your life who loves toffee but can’t have nuts. Eat it as a candy, or crush and sprinkle some atop any number of things to add a touch of crunch and caramel flavor.

Visit:Christina’s Cucina

Peanut brittle is one of the most classic Christmas candies. What’s not to love? Peanuts and sugar come together in this light, crispy candy. It’s perfect for gift giving and always a crowd pleaser.

Visit:Garnish and Glaze

This recipe has two components that made me pause before categorizing it. Ultimately, it’s listed under toffee because it is a major component of this recipe. A twist on a classic Christmas Toffee, the typical saltines are switched out with chocolate graham crackers, and white chocolate is used instead of milk chocolate for a completely new take on this holiday favorite.

Visit:Our Wabi Sabi Life

Another nut-free option for those who need it, this sesame seed crunch candy uses only three ingredients to achieve a toasty, crunchy result. Looking for a vegan option of this candy? Inside you’ll find a link to a bee-free honey you can substitute instead.

Visit:Strength and Sunshine

Fleur de sel tops this luscious combination of brown butter toffee and chocolate which comes together as an indulgent treat. The classic flavor combinations are sure to please anyone lucky enough to receive this as a gift.

Visit:The Spice Train

This recipe uses a classic toffee recipe so many of us are familiar with, but shakes it up with the addition of pumpkin spice to give it a holiday feel. Finished with pecans, the flavors meld into a sweet and spicy dream.

Visit:What a Girl Eats

Christmas Fudge & Chocolate Candy

Old Fashioned maple and walnut fudge is such a classic. Using real maple syrup makes the flavors in this fudge unreal. It’s creamy and rich and the creamy texture will have you coming back for more.

Visit:Frugal Mom Eh

In this version of white chocolate rocky road, you’ll find a combination of pistachios, dried apricots and cranberries, coconuts, and marshmallows. When cut, the beautiful color combinations delight the eye, while the flavor delights your tastebuds.

Visit:It’s Not Complicated Recipes

A slight variation from our version one featured recipe, this recipe uses a combination of pistachios, macadamia nuts, marshmallows, dried cranberries, and soft jelly lollies. Another eye-catching treat when cut, this simple Christmas candy gift is perfect for gift-giving.

Visit:Recipe Pocket

These delightful pieces of chocolate will melt in your mouth. They are so smooth and rich, they make for the perfect bite-size dessert after any meal. If you can make a ganache, you can make this rich, delicious candy.

Visit:One Pot Only

One of the simpler fudge recipes available, this tiger butter fudge showcases peanut butter, white chocolate, and chocolate flavors in this quick and easy recipe. No thermometer needed!

Visit:Recipe Pocket

The base of this recipe is literally only two ingredients and you can prepare it in the microwave! If you’re looking for a super simple Christmas candy recipe, this is it. Doll it up by changing it up however you like. Two variations featured in this post include a white chocolate, cranberry, and pistachio fudge, and a dark chocolate, walnut, and pistachio variety. You really can do so much with this basic recipe.

Visit:Vintage Kitchen Notes

Christmas Truffles

Multiple layers of flavors make up these “Mother-In-Law’s Eyes”. Graham crackers, coconut, fruit jellies, and chocolate come together to create these eye-catching treats.

Visit:All That’s Jas

For the peanut butter lover in your life, you’ve got to check this one out. The rich, sweet peanut butter and brown sugar center is coated by a layer of peanut butter candy melts and a drizzle of chocolate for the classic flavor combination.

Visit: Christmas Crafts and Recipes

You won’t believe how easy it is to make luscious Marzipan Chocolates. Soft, sweet balls of almond candy are enrobed in a dark chocolate shell. Use homemade marzipan, or store bought, to create beautiful confections that add sparkle to dessert trays, and make great gifts and care package treats.

Visit:The Monday Box

A creamy, peanut buttery center gets coated by a semi-sweet chocolate to create the most perfect flavor combination. You may know these as “buckeyes” if the chocolate coating is left with the peanut butter showing.

Visit:The Short Order Cook

This recipe uses pre-made hollow chocolate spheres to make these gorgeous truffles even more simple to prepare. Filled with a delicious salted caramel, these truffles are the ultimate holiday indulgence.

Visit:Vividly Christmas

Miscellaneous Christmas Candies

Use navel or Valencia oranges to create these delightful candied orange peels. Gift them as they are or dip them in chocolate for an extra flare.

Visit:Bright Eyed Baker

Though coconut is a “love it or leave it” ingredient, for those who love it, these are the perfect holiday candy gift. Unlike other Mounds copycat recipes, this one does not use condensed milk, which means the center isn’t as cloyingly as sweet.

Visit:Christina’s Cucina

These breakable chocolate balls are so fun! Your recipient gets to smash open their gift and find whatever you decide to put inside, in this instance candy. This is a gift that would really benefit from a unique presentation. Pair it with a small, wooden mallet to make it even more fun.

Visit:Christmas Crafts and Recipes

The perfect make-ahead gift, these homemade caramels store really well and everyone loves them. Make several batches and share with those you love.

Visit:Garnish and Glaze

This unique recipe features peppermint mocha Coffee-Mate creamer rather than the typical condensed milk for a less intensely sweet middle, yet still maintains that classic peppermint chocolate flavor.

Visit:Happiness is Homemade

This Hedgehog Slice is the ideal no-bake chocolate dessert. It is quick to make and easily adapted to be gluten-free. Crushed biscuits, coconut and chocolate combine for one of the most simple, yet delicious sweet treats!

Visit:It’s Not Complicated Recipes

Unlike the candied orange peels shared above, this recipe uses the entire fruit. The crystalized citrus is delicious on its own and pairs nicely when dipped in dark chocolate.

Visit:Recipe Pocket

Possibly the most quintessential Christmas candy, the turtle is a beloved favorite of many people. Not only are they delicious, but they look beautiful when presented as a gift.

Visit:The Cagle Diaries

Super easy to make, these 3 ingredients candies are delicious and always a hit. Make them in mini or regular sized muffin liners, either way they’ll be gobbled up.

Visit:The Food Blog

Quite possibly the quickest candy to put together, these two ingredient sweets are the perfect last-minute treat. Simply melt the chocolate, stir in the nuts, and let it cool. Quick and easy, but also delicious.

Visit:Vintage Kitchen Notes

Once I’ve decided on Christmas candy gifts for friends or family, I love choosing how I will present them. My favorite way to give food gifts is in a reusable Christmas tin. Line the bottom with parchment and for individual treats, use small food cups like the ones shared here. Check out all of theChristmas Food Gift Containerson Amazon, or click directly on the ones linked below.

Which recipes will you be making for your Christmas candy gifts this year? Please be sure to stop by the linked posts and show the blog some love. Let us know how you liked these recipes and if you tried any of them. Tag us on social media or leave a comment below.

Related Post: